Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Edu Manzano, Jeminah Birkner question who really benefits from Pax Silica

Actor Edu Manzano and Filipino-German content creator Jeminah Birkner are raising questions about the proposed Pax Silica initiative, urging Filipinos to look beyond promises of economic progress and examine who stands to benefit and who could bear its consequences.

In separate social media posts, the two personalities questioned the implications of development projects that could affect the country’s natural resources, local communities, and livelihoods.

Who benefits from progress?

Manzano stressed that the country’s mountains, rivers, forests, and lands should not be treated as disposable resources in exchange for promises of progress.

He pointed out the need for transparency and accountability, saying the public deserves clear information about the plans, meaningful consultations with affected communities, and thorough studies before decisions are made.

“We need jobs and opportunities. Pero progreso ba talaga kung kapalit nito ang pangamba sa tahanan, kabuhayan, tubig at likas na yaman?” he asked.

The actor also questioned who would ultimately benefit from the initiative, particularly given what he described as the government’s record on transparency and accountability.

Privilege is not immunity

Meanwhile, Birkner, a content creator, photographer, entrepreneur, and co-founder of Isla Magazine, delivered a more pointed message about the consequences of environmental destruction and the silence of privileged Filipinos.

She argued that access to clean water, food, breathable air, and a safe place to live transcends wealth, political affiliations, and social standing.

“Just do not mistake your privilege for immunity,” she warned, challenging comfortable Filipinos who remain indifferent to the struggles of communities affected by development projects.

Birkner stressed that the loss of forests, the displacement of communities, and the destruction of natural resources would eventually affect everyone, not just those directly impacted.

Principles over politicians

She also clarified that questioning development does not mean opposing progress, advocating instead for responsible development, regenerative agriculture, sustainable industries, and innovation that does not come at the expense of the country’s natural heritage.

In another pointed statement, she urged Filipinos to put principles above political personalities.

“Don’t defend personalities. Defend principles. Don’t worship politicians. Demand accountability,” she said.

Both Manzano and Birkner ultimately called for development that considers the welfare of ordinary Filipinos and protects the country’s resources for future generations.

Their messages raise a bigger question about the kind of progress the Philippines should pursue: one measured by investment figures and economic promises, or one that also considers the people, communities, and environment that stand to be affected.