Male victims of sexual abuse suffer twice under gendered rape laws — SC
Woman who abused 11-year-old nephew convicted of statutory acts of lasciviousness; rape law did not cover her acts

The Supreme Court has underscored that men can also be victims of sexual violence, stressing that the law must protect all victims of abuse regardless of gender.
In a decision written by Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen—promulgated on Feb. 4, 2026, and published on Oct. 23—the SC En Banc found a woman guilty of sexually abusing her 11-year-old nephew in 2018.
The child was visiting his father’s relatives when the woman woke him while he was asleep, ordered him to remove his clothes, and made him lie on her bed before engaging in sexual intercourse with him.
The boy initially did not resist because he was curious about what was happening, but later felt ashamed and considered ending his life. He was eventually diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder following psychological debriefing and supportive psychotherapy.
The woman argued that the child had consented, but the SC disagreed. At the time, the age of consent was 12—and the boy was only 11.
The SC also said the boy’s initial lack of resistance did not undermine his account, stressing that victims should not be expected to react in a particular way when they experience abuse.
Statutory acts of lasciviousness
The woman was held liable for statutory acts of lasciviousness under Article 336 of the Revised Penal Code. This is distinct from acts of lasciviousness under Section 5(b) of Republic Act No. 7610.
Citing Gramatica v. People in 2025, Leonen explained that acts of lasciviousness “only applies when a minor gives a semblance of consent, albeit flawed, to sexual intercourse or lascivious conduct due to the coercion or influence of an adult.”
It does not apply where a minor is “entirely unaware, unconscious, or, in this case, unable to give legal consent.”
The woman was sentenced to imprisonment ranging from nine years, four months and one day to 16 years, five months and nine days. She was also ordered to pay the victim ₱150,000 in civil indemnity, ₱50,000 in moral damages, and ₱50,000 in exemplary damages.
Not rape under the law
Leonen said the woman’s acts did not fall within the definition of rape under Article 266-A of the RPC.
Under the provision, rape was defined as a man having “carnal knowledge of a woman” under any of these circumstances: when the act was committed through force, threat, or intimidation; when the victim was deprived of reason or unconscious; through fraudulent machination or grave abuse of authority; or when the victim was below 12 years old or had dementia, regardless of whether any of the other circumstances were present.
This changed with the passage of Republic Act No. 11648 on March 4, 2022. The law raised the age of sexual consent from 12 to 16 and made the definition of rape gender-neutral, replacing the phrase “a man who shall have carnal knowledge of a woman” with “a person who shall have carnal knowledge of another person.”
“However, as it stands, the acts penalized are not within the limits of rape as provided by law,” Leonen said.
Patriarchal roots of rape laws
Leonen traced the gendered definition of rape to the patriarchal roots of rape laws, which he said were originally created not to penalize violence against women, but to punish men who took women—then regarded as the property of their husbands and fathers—through rape and abduction.
He also noted that even after RA 11648 made the definition of rape gender-neutral, some court rulings continued to interpret carnal knowledge narrowly, limiting it to the “penetration of the female sexual organ by the sexual organ of the male.”
“These views on rape are not only misogynistic, they also disenfranchise male victims who have less redress in law, but are inflicted with the same trauma,” Leonen said, adding that the lack of recognition that men can be victims of sexual violence also impairs their ability to recognize that they have been violated.
For Leonen, rape must be viewed “not only through the lens of gender but, more importantly, of power,” as it is an imposition of someone’s dominance to violate the bodily autonomy of another.” The imbalance, he said, can stem from differences in gender, age, socioeconomic status, professional authority, or education.
In this case, Leonen said, the woman used her age and moral ascendancy to coerce her 11-year-old nephew “into satisfying her lewd intentions.”
While recognizing the historical injustice women have suffered, Leonen said the law and its interpretation “must be resilient enough to provide equal protection to all victims and guard against stereotypes that all women are victims and all men are perpetrators.”
“When laws are not gender-neutral, male victims suffer twice: once at the hands of their abuser and second through the judicial system,” he said.
He also called for a reevaluation of whether the historical justifications for distinctions in rape laws remain relevant and fair.
“The law has long defined rape by the conduct of the perpetrator, yet this captures only part of the truth,” Leonen said. “The violation and loss of dignity endured by the victim must also be taken into the equation. By doing this, the law can pave the way to humanize the victims and vindicate the harm they have endured.”
READ:
Teen sexual abuse survivors feel ‘death-like’ loss but show resilience, faith, altruism
Nikko Miguel Garcia
June 5, 2026
Bicol writers’ group says no space for abusers amid claims vs Albay ‘D.O.M.’
radar Lifestyle
September 14, 2026
Barefoot Theatre Collaborative producer steps back amid sexual harassment allegations
Nikko Miguel Garcia
May 29, 2026
