Is Philippine art getting dumber?

After asking why the artist kept painting the same subject instead of exploring new ideas, she recalled receiving a blunt but honest answer: “Baka hindi bilhin. At least ito sigurado.”

The exchange prompted Alcantara to revisit an idea she called “Art Unintelligencing,” which she described as the gradual “de-intellectualization” or, as some have bluntly put it, the “dumbing down” of art.

She said the more she listened to conversations among artists, critics, collectors, and other cultural workers, the more she realized they were all describing the same phenomenon from different perspectives.

“Art has become easier to consume than to contemplate,” Alcantara wrote. “Works were presented more as branding than ideas. Familiarity is rewarded over experimentation. The market favors what is recognizable, repeatable, and low risk.”

According to her, artists increasingly feel pressured to produce works that are easier to sell rather than challenge themselves creatively, while galleries, dealers, social media algorithms, and the broader economy reinforce the demand for familiar and commercially viable art.

She also pointed to industry practices that made her question the direction of the market, including limited-edition artworks released in multiple editions, expensive reproductions marketed as making art more accessible, and galleries increasingly functioning like talent agencies that build artists into brands.

At one point, Alcantara humorously compared the art market to Pokémon card collecting, saying both seemed driven by rarity, branding, editions, and collectors chasing the next coveted object.

Despite her criticisms, Alcantara acknowledged that change is inevitable.

“The art world is evolving. Markets evolve. Collectors evolve. Artists evolve. Galleries evolve,” she wrote.

She said the more important question is how the industry chooses to evolve—whether it continues rewarding familiarity and stronger branding, or deliberately creates more space for experimentation, difficult ideas, and works that ask more questions than they answer.

“As artists, galleries, collectors, and cultural custodians, we don’t just participate in the art ecosystem—we shape it,” she said.

Alcantara is a prominent Filipino art curator, consultant, and writer who currently serves as curator of Art Circle Gallery. She is widely recognized for advocating art education, critical engagement with contemporary art, and thoughtful discussions on the direction of the Philippine art market.

READ: